Top 15 Italian Restaurants in NYC: From Classic to Contemporary (2025 Guide)

70 / 100

SEO Score

New York City’s Italian food scene offers everything from old-world family establishments that have perfected recipes over generations to modern interpretations reimagining Italian classics with local ingredients and innovative techniques. Whether you’re craving perfectly executed pasta, authentic Neapolitan pizza or sophisticated Northern Italian cuisine, NYC delivers some of the finest Italian dining experiences outside of Italy itself. This curated guide highlights the absolute best Italian restaurants in NYC for every occasion, budget and neighborhood.

Carbone (Greenwich Village)

Address: 181 Thompson Street
Reservation Difficulty: Very High

Since opening in 2013, Carbone has defined modern Italian-American fine dining with its theatrical approach to classic dishes. Under Major Food Group’s direction, this Greenwich Village hotspot elevates red-sauce traditions with impeccable technique and premium ingredients. The tableside Caesar salad preparation alone justifies the considerable expense, while the spicy rigatoni vodka has achieved near-mythical status among pasta enthusiasts.

The tuxedoed waitstaff, vintage décor, and Sinatra-era soundtrack create an immersive experience that transports diners to mid-century Italian-American dining at its zenith. Securing a reservation remains one of NYC’s greatest dining challenges, often requiring planning months ahead or strategic refreshing of reservation platforms.

Signature dish: Spicy rigatoni vodka featuring handmade pasta in a velvety, chile-spiked cream sauce.

Bamonte’s (Williamsburg)

Address: 32 Withers Street, Brooklyn
Reservation Difficulty: Moderate

Serving Williamsburg since 1900, Bamonte’s represents Brooklyn Italian-American heritage at its most authentic. The restaurant’s time-capsule quality—with tuxedoed waiters, red leather booths, and walls adorned with celebrity photos spanning decades—provides a genuine connection to the neighborhood’s Italian roots.

The menu focuses on perfectly executed classics rather than innovation: clams oreganata, eggplant parmigiana, and veal scallopine satisfy deep cravings for tradition. The house specialty, pork chops with vinegar peppers, delivers a perfect balance of savory and tangy flavors with fork-tender meat. Remarkably, despite the national attention Bamonte’s has received, prices remain reasonable compared to Manhattan counterparts.

Signature dish: Pork chops with vinegar peppers, a Sicilian-influenced specialty balancing rich meat with acidic brightness.

Rezdôra (Flatiron District)

Address: 27 East 20th Street
Reservation Difficulty: Very High

Chef Stefano Secchi’s Emilia-Romagna focused restaurant quickly earned its Michelin star through extraordinary pasta and regional specialties rarely seen outside of Northern Italy. The restaurant’s name—dialect for “grandmother” in Modena—reflects its dedication to traditional techniques while incorporating modern sensibilities.

The five-course pasta tasting menu offers an education in regional styles, from Modena’s delicate tortellini to Parma’s robust anolini. Beyond pasta, Rezdôra excels with exceptional salumi, perfectly prepared seasonal vegetables, and sophisticated meat courses like the rabbit all cacciatore. The thoughtfully curated wine list showcases lesser-known producers from Emilia-Romagna alongside established Italian favorites.

Signature dish: Cappelletti verdi, spinach pasta filled with roasted leeks and delicate stracciatella cheese in a butter sauce.

Lilia (Williamsburg)

Address: 567 Union Avenue, Brooklyn
Reservation Difficulty: Very High

Chef Missy Robbins established herself as NYC’s pasta queen with Lilia, transforming a former auto body shop into Brooklyn’s most coveted Italian reservation. Her approach combines rigorous technique with a less-is-more philosophy, allowing superior ingredients to shine through uncomplicated preparations.

The mafaldine with pink peppercorns and Parmigiano showcases Robbins’ gift for elevating simple components into something transcendent. The wood-fired grill contributes distinctive char to vegetables and proteins, while the cacio e pepe fritelle (cheese and pepper fritters) have spawned countless imitations citywide. The airy, whitewashed space with soaring ceilings provides a contemporary backdrop that keeps focus on the exceptional food.

Signature dish: Sheep’s milk cheese-filled agnolotti with honey and saffron, achieving perfect balance between savory and sweet notes.

Don Angie (West Village)

Address: 103 Greenwich Avenue
Reservation Difficulty: Very High

Husband-and-wife team Angie Rito and Scott Tacinelli created a modern Italian-American institution with their stylish West Village restaurant. Their inventive yet approachable menu reimagines familiar flavor combinations with unexpected presentations, exemplified by their Instagram-famous lasagna for two—a pinwheel-shaped creation layering pasta with sweet Italian sausage and creamy besciamella.

The chrysanthemum salad with pears, pancetta, and pecorino demonstrates their talent for balanced composition, while the buffalo milk caramelle pasta with duck prosciutto showcases their pasta-making virtuosity. The intimate corner space with checkerboard floors and curved banquettes creates a sophisticated yet comfortable setting for their creative interpretations.

Signature dish: Pinwheel lasagna for two, a visually stunning reinvention of the classic baked pasta with ruffled edges and perfectly distributed fillings.

Via Carota (West Village)

Address: 51 Grove Street
Reservation Difficulty: Very High

Chefs Jody Williams and Rita Sodi combined their considerable talents in this beloved West Village spot that captures the rustic elegance of Tuscan dining. The no-reservations policy hasn’t deterred persistent crowds drawn to their vegetable-forward menu and perfectly executed classics.

The insalata verde—a towering, precisely dressed green salad—demonstrates their commitment to transforming simple ingredients through meticulous technique. Seasonal vegetable antipasti change regularly, while pasta dishes like wild boar ragu over pappardelle maintain Italian authenticity without compromise. The charming space, with antique furniture and rustic wooden tables, completes the transportive experience.

Signature dish: Cacio e pepe, a deceptively simple Roman classic executed with extraordinary precision, creating the perfect emulsion of cheese, pepper, and pasta water.

Una Pizza Napoletana (Lower East Side)

Address: 175 Orchard Street
Reservation Difficulty: Moderate

Anthony Mangieri’s single-minded pursuit of pizza perfection has established him as America’s premier pizzaiolo. His Lower East Side restaurant focuses exclusively on naturally leavened Neapolitan pizzas cooked in a wood-fired oven, with a minimalist menu that emphasizes quality over variety.

The Margherita DOC—featuring San Marzano tomatoes, Buffalo mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, and fresh basil—achieves ethereal lightness with pronounced charring and a tender, pillowy crust. The sparse, industrial space eliminates distractions, focusing attention squarely on the pizza-making craft visible from every seat. For pizza purists, no NYC visit is complete without experiencing Mangieri’s transcendent creations.

Signature dish: Margherita DOC, the quintessential Neapolitan pizza executed with unmatched attention to fermentation, ingredient quality, and cooking technique.

Lucali (Carroll Gardens)

Address: 575 Henry Street, Brooklyn
Reservation Difficulty: Very High

Mark Iacono’s candlelit Carroll Gardens pizzeria has achieved cult status for its thin-crust pies and BYOB policy. The restaurant’s famous no-reservations system creates nightly lines of devoted fans willing to wait hours for Iacono’s meticulously crafted pizzas, each made using his grandmother’s rolling pin.

The limited menu—just pizza and calzones with optional toppings—reflects Lucali’s singular focus on perfecting its core offerings. The pizza strikes a brilliant balance between New York and Neapolitan styles, with a thin, structured crust that maintains both crispness and chew. The restaurant’s romantic lighting and unpretentious charm make it equally suitable for first dates or casual dinners with friends.

Signature dish: Plain pizza with basil and garlic, showcasing the perfect harmony of sweet-acidic tomato sauce and three-cheese blend on a beautifully charred crust.

L’Industrie Pizzeria (Williamsburg)

Address: 254 South 2nd Street, Brooklyn
Reservation Difficulty: None (Counter Service)

What began as a humble slice shop has evolved into Brooklyn’s most exciting pizza destination, combining New York tradition with Italian technique. Massimo Laveglia’s unassuming Williamsburg storefront produces extraordinary pies distinguished by exceptionally long fermentation and premium Italian ingredients.

The burrata slice—topped with creamy cheese added post-bake—has become their signature, but the simple cheese slice reveals the true caliber of their dough development and sauce. Recent expansion into the adjacent space has added seating but maintained the unpretentious atmosphere. The remarkable quality-to-price ratio makes L’Industrie an essential stop for pizza enthusiasts.

Signature dish: Burrata slice, featuring their perfectly structured crust topped with fresh, creamy cheese that creates a luxurious textural contrast.

Fiaschetteria “Pistoia” (East Village/West Village)

Address:

647 East 11th Street (East Village)
114 Christopher Street (West Village)

Reservation Difficulty: Moderate

These twin Tuscan trattorias bring authentic regional cooking to intimate village settings. Chef Emanuele Bugiani’s focused menu highlights traditional Tuscan dishes rarely found in American Italian restaurants, from pappardelle with wild boar ragu to ribollita (bread soup with vegetables).

The handwritten menu changes frequently based on seasonal availability, while the all-Italian wine list emphasizes small producers from Tuscany at reasonable price points. Both locations recreate the feeling of neighborhood restaurants found throughout central Italy, with rustic décor and genuine hospitality that encourages lingering over multiple courses.

Signature dish: Pappardelle al cinghiale, wide ribbons of pasta with slow-cooked wild boar ragu seasoned with juniper and herbs.

Popina (Columbia Waterfront District)

Address: 127 Columbia Street, Brooklyn
Reservation Difficulty: Low

This charming Brooklyn spot uniquely blends Italian technique with Southern American influences, reflecting chef Chris McDade’s background in both culinary traditions. The result feels coherent rather than forced fusion, with dishes like hot chicken Milanese bridging cultural divides through thoughtful execution.

The restaurant’s hidden backyard provides one of Brooklyn’s most pleasant outdoor dining experiences, while the pasta offerings—particularly the ricotta gnocchi with pork ragu—deliver exceptional value. The approachable wine list emphasizes sustainable producers and lesser-known Italian regions at accessible price points.

Signature dish: Hot chicken Milanese, combining the crispy Italian preparation with Nashville hot chicken spices, served with honey and pickles.

Forsythia (Lower East Side)

Address: 9 Stanton Street
Reservation Difficulty: Moderate

Chef Jacob Siwak’s Roman-focused restaurant delivers extraordinary pasta and seasonal antipasti in an unpretentious Lower East Side setting. The compact menu emphasizes quality over quantity, with expertly executed classics alongside creative seasonal offerings.

The cacio e pepe supplì (fried rice balls filled with the famous pasta preparation) exemplifies their approach to tradition with playful twists, while pasta dishes like mezze maniche all’amatriciana maintain rigorous authenticity. The restaurant’s affordable price point belies the kitchen’s fine-dining pedigree, making it a remarkable value for handmade pasta of this caliber.

Signature dish: Tonnarelli cacio e pepe, square-cut spaghetti with the perfect emulsion of pecorino Romano and black pepper.

Torrisi Bar & Restaurant (SoHo)

Address: 275 Mulberry Street
Reservation Difficulty: Very High

Chef Rich Torrisi’s triumphant return to fine dining reimagines Italian-American cuisine through a luxurious lens. The SoHo restaurant combines meticulous technique with nostalgic flavor profiles, resulting in sophisticated interpretations of familiar classics.

The duck Marsala for two—featuring dry-aged breast and confit leg—elevates the Italian-American staple to fine dining heights without losing its soulful appeal. The restaurant’s elegant interior, featuring a central bar and intimate dining room with custom terrazzo floors, creates a suitably refined backdrop for the ambitious menu. While decidedly expensive, the experience justifies the investment for special occasions.

Signature dish: Lobster ravioli in tomato sauce, featuring delicate pasta filled with sweet Maine lobster in a complex, layered tomato preparation.

Ci Siamo (Hudson Yards)

Address: 440 West 33rd Street
Reservation Difficulty: High

Chef Hillary Sterling’s ambitious restaurant centers around wood-fired cooking, creating distinctive char and smoke notes throughout the Italian-inspired menu. The spacious Hudson Yards location provides views of the hearth from nearly every table, highlighting the primacy of flame in Sterling’s cooking philosophy.

The deceptively simple preparations—like whole roasted artichokes with preserved lemon aioli—showcase Sterling’s talent for coaxing maximum flavor through careful technique. Pasta dishes, particularly the rigatoni with white bolognese, demonstrate equal finesse away from the flames. The restaurant’s warm woods and earth tones create an inviting atmosphere despite the large footprint.

Signature dish: Wood-roasted chicken for two with salsa verde, achieving perfectly crisp skin and succulent meat through precise hearth cooking.

Misi (Williamsburg)

Address: 329 Kent Avenue, Brooklyn
Reservation Difficulty: Very High

Chef Missy Robbins’ follow-up to Lilia maintains her focus on pasta excellence while exploring vegetable preparations with equal finesse. The expansive open kitchen puts pasta-making on display, with dedicated stations visible from the minimalist dining room.

The menu structure—divided simply between vegetable antipasti and pasta—emphasizes Robbins’ less-is-more philosophy. Seasonal vegetables shine through careful preparation and judicious enhancement, while pasta dishes like occhi filled with sheep’s milk ricotta showcase technical virtuosity through apparent simplicity. The sleek, contemporary space in South Williamsburg complements the refined, ingredient-focused cuisine.

Signature dish: Fettuccine with buffalo butter, providing a masterclass in how extraordinary ingredients need minimal intervention when handled with expertise.

F&F Pizzeria (Carroll Gardens)

Address: 459 Court Street, Brooklyn
Reservation Difficulty: None (Counter Service)

This collaboration between pizza legend Frank Falcinelli (Frankies 457) and bread master Chad Robertson (Tartine) produces exceptional square slices using naturally fermented dough with extraordinary flavor development. The bare-bones Carroll Gardens storefront focuses exclusively on pizza quality, with minimal seating and streamlined service.

The classic cheese slice—featuring crushed tomatoes, caciocavallo cheese, and Sicilian oregano on a remarkably light, airy crust—demonstrates how transformative proper fermentation can be to familiar forms. At around $4 per substantial slice, F&F delivers perhaps the best quality-to-price ratio in NYC’s Italian food landscape.

Signature dish: Classic cheese square slice, featuring a distinctively light, open crumb structure with exceptional depth of flavor from extended fermentation.

Il Posto Accanto (East Village)

Address: 190 East 2nd Street
Reservation Difficulty: Low

This intimate wine bar has served the East Village for over two decades, offering authentic Italian small plates and expertly curated wines in an unpretentious setting. The tiny space—just a handful of tables and a small bar—creates an atmosphere of conviviality that encourages neighborhood regulars and first-time visitors to engage over shared plates.

The kitchen excels with straightforward preparations highlighting quality ingredients: burrata with prosciutto, sautéed broccoli rabe, and perfectly executed pasta specials. The extensive Italian wine list emphasizes small producers across multiple price points, with knowledgeable staff providing thoughtful guidance. For authentic Italian atmosphere without formality or high prices, Il Posto Accanto remains unmatched.

Signature dish: Spaghetti al limone, a deceptively simple preparation balanced perfectly between bright citrus notes and rich butter.

Navigating NYC’s Italian Dining Scene: Insider Tips

Reservation Strategies

For highly sought-after restaurants like Carbone and Rezdôra:

Set calendar alerts for reservation release dates (typically 30 days out)
Check for cancellations daily, especially 48 hours before desired dates
Consider dining at off-peak hours (5:30pm or after 9:30pm)
Solo diners can often secure bar seating without advance planning

Seasonal Specialties Worth Seeking

Spring: Look for ramp-focused dishes at Via Carota and Lilia
Summer: Tomato-centric menus shine at Misi and Don Angie
Fall: White truffle menus appear at Rezdôra and Torrisi
Winter: Hearty braises and game meats feature prominently at Ci Siamo and Popina

Budget-Friendly Italian Experiences

Beyond the restaurants listed, consider:

Arthur Avenue in the Bronx for authentic markets and affordable trattorias
Italian sandwich shops like Faicco’s and Alidoro for lunch under $15
Happy hour specials at Forsythia (5-6pm) and Il Posto Accanto (4-7pm)

Experience NYC’s Extraordinary Italian Food Scene

From century-old institutions preserving Italian-American heritage to innovative chefs reimagining regional traditions, New York City offers unparalleled diversity and quality in Italian dining. Whether seeking a memorable special occasion destination or an authentic neighborhood experience, the restaurants highlighted provide exceptional value and distinctive character at every price point.

Have you visited any of these outstanding Italian restaurants? Share your experiences and favorite dishes in the comments below! For personalized recommendations based on your specific preferences, neighborhood or upcoming visit dates, subscribe to our The City Stuff Food Insider newsletter featuring special reservation opportunities and chef interviews.