New York City is home to some of the best Italian restaurants in the world, ranging from rustic trattorias to Michelin-starred fine dining. Whether you’re a fan of handmade pasta, Neapolitan pizza, or seafood-rich coastal fare, the city has something to satisfy every craving. If you’re asking, “What is the most famous Italian restaurant in New York?” or searching for the #1 Italian restaurant in NYC, this list brings together the top 10 Italian restaurants in New York—each one celebrated for its signature style, ambiance, and the most popular dishes in Italian restaurants.

List of Top 10 Italian Restaurants in NYC

1. Carbone – #1 Italian Restaurant in NYC

Carbone is perhaps the most famous Italian restaurant in New York, known for its glamorous setting and iconic red-sauce menu. Signature dishes like spicy rigatoni vodka and veal parmesan are among the most popular dishes in Italian restaurants citywide. Located in Greenwich Village, Carbone blends nostalgic décor with elevated Italian-American cuisine. Celebrities, locals, and tourists flock here, making it a true NYC dining landmark. This is without question a 5-star Italian restaurant in New York City, and if you’re hunting for the best Italian restaurants in NYC, Carbone tops the list.

2. Don Angie – Popular Italian Restaurant in NYC

Located in the West Village, Don Angie is a modern Italian-American spot with a Michelin star and a cult following. Famous for its lasagna pinwheels and inventive cocktails, it’s a popular Italian restaurant in NYC that’s both romantic and cutting-edge. A go-to for date nights and celebrations, it’s frequently featured on lists of the top 10 Italian restaurants in New York. For fans of new-age Italian cooking, Don Angie is a 5-star Italian restaurant in New York City not to miss.

3. Rezdôra – Regional Northern Italian Mastery

Rezdôra, located in Flatiron, specializes in the rich, pasta-focused cuisine of Emilia-Romagna. Dishes like tagliolini al ragu and tortellini in brodo are among the most popular dishes in Italian restaurants with serious culinary roots. Known for authenticity and technique, it’s a must for fans of traditional Italian flavors. Often cited among the best Italian restaurants in NYC, Rezdôra offers a true regional experience in a warm, modern setting.

4. Via Carota – Rustic Elegance in the West Village

Via Carota is the epitome of rustic Italian charm. This popular Italian restaurant in NYC doesn’t take reservations, yet it draws long lines daily. Their cacio e pepe, insalata verde, and olive oil cake are some of the most popular dishes in Italian restaurants across Manhattan. Consistently ranking in the top 10 Italian restaurants in New York, Via Carota blends simplicity with sophistication like no other.

5. Torrisi Bar & Restaurant – Modern Italian Glamour

Torrisi in Nolita is one of the city’s most theatrical and elevated Italian experiences. From the team behind Carbone, it offers bold dishes like duck alla mulberry and saffron raviolini. Its luxurious setting and inventive menu have earned it a spot in the top 10 Italian restaurants in NYC. If you’re wondering, “What is the most famous Italian restaurant in New York” for trend-setting cuisine, Torrisi is your answer.

6. Lilia – Brooklyn’s Pasta Paradise

In Williamsburg, Lilia stands out for its sleek design and handmade pasta. Chef Missy Robbins serves dishes like mafaldini with pink peppercorns and wood-grilled clams, making it a standout among the best Italian restaurants in NYC. As a 5-star Italian restaurant in New York City, it’s ideal for both casual and special nights out. Lilia is a destination for anyone serious about pasta done right.

7. I Sodi – Minimalist Tuscan Excellence

I Sodi is a serene West Village treasure that honors Tuscan simplicity. Its artichoke lasagna and lemon pappardelle are consistently rated among the most popular dishes in Italian restaurants. Quiet and elegant, it’s a perfect date-night spot and a recurring name on top 10 Italian restaurants in New York lists. If you’re looking for restraint, refinement, and excellence, this is your place.

8. Marea – Michelin-Starred Seafood Italian

Marea offers a refined take on coastal Italian cuisine near Central Park. Known for its fusilli with octopus and bone marrow, this 5-star Italian restaurant in New York City appeals to seafood lovers and fine-dining enthusiasts. The elegant ambiance and expert service make it one of the best Italian restaurants in NYC, ideal for celebrations and business dinners alike.

9. Frankies 457 Spuntino – Charming Brooklyn Classic

Frankies 457 is a beloved popular Italian restaurant in NYC, offering a warm atmosphere and consistently excellent food. Located in Carroll Gardens, it’s known for cavatelli with sausage and backyard dining. This neighborhood gem is often named among the top 10 Italian restaurants in New York for casual dining. Its welcoming vibe and flavorful, no-fuss menu win over first-timers and regulars alike.

10. Emilio’s Ballato – Old-School Italian Legend

Emilio’s Ballato is a throwback to classic NYC Italian-American dining. Founded in the 1950s and still family-run, it’s a favorite of celebrities, politicians, and food lovers alike. With dishes like spaghetti pomodoro and chicken parmigiana, it serves some of the most popular dishes in Italian restaurants today. No reservations, no frills—just great food and timeless charm. A true answer to “What is the most famous Italian restaurant in New York.”

🍝 Finding the Best Italian Restaurants in NYC

Whether you’re dining in Brooklyn, SoHo, or the West Village, these top 10 Italian restaurants in NYC deliver unforgettable experiences through food, atmosphere, and service. From 5-star Italian restaurants in New York City to cozy neighborhood gems, there’s no shortage of places serving the most popular dishes in Italian restaurants. If you’re wondering where to go next or trying to decide on the #1 Italian restaurant in NYC, this list is your ultimate guide. Buon appetito!